The feedback for our post about crisis followership was much appreciated and we hope this update adds similar value to your preparations. In that previous post we discussed a view on the nature of leadership, it's connection with followership and the art of being a good follower. In this post we'll examine crisis through the lens of the leader and explain how this might help your preparations as crisis leaders.
Accepting that 'leadership' (noun) has three dimensions (leader, follower, context) and that these three must be in harmony for 'leadership' to be present, it's clear that a leader must influence all dimensions, especially in a crisis. Impacting in an unbalanced way or failing to have any impact on these dimensions will restrict the effectiveness of the response to a crisis.
So What?
Accepting all that's been said thus far it's therefore an easy step to appreciate that the crisis leader must (yes, must) deliberately seek to influence all three dimensions for best effect. This is perhaps equally as true for the day to day challenges of leadership as it is for times of crisis.
Context. Crisis leaders must exercise judgement and skill in influencing the context for a positive effect. This requires them to understand the situation and its implications for their people, their organisation and the impacts on other interested parties (customers and regulators for example). Leaders must make decisions based on this clarity of understanding with a view to generating actions and safeguarding against unintended consequences. And those supporting leaders must identify when and how these actions are having an effect on the context(s) and feed this information back for further decisions. All of this requires crisis leaders to be clear about the three questions of context: where are we now, where do we want to get to and how are we going to achieve this.
Followers. This group was the subject of the previous post. From a leader's perspective, connecting with followers both within and beyond the organisation in a way that resonates is key to altering the context in your favour. It'll be a challenge for leaders to try and establish this rapport as the waves of crisis break over their heads; lay the groundwork to build these relationships and connections now. Develop an understanding of followers' expectations and of 'what makes them tick' and use this thoughtfully during times of crisis.
Leaders. In the course of our work we often come across those who believe that a totally different model of leadership applies in times of crisis. Its true that leaders must respond to the context(s) within which they are operating but it doesn't follow that anything goes as far as leaders' behaviour is concerned. In fact the reverse is true; crisis intensifies the spotlight and pressure on leaders at all levels. Remaining mindful of your behaviour, coping with pressure and maintaining a clarity of mind and of purpose is more important than ever. Exercise the arts of leadership to lead by example and trust that your followers are skilled enough to help keep you on track.
By consciously operating within and upon the three dimensions of 'leadership', crisis leaders stand a better chance of success. Practice makes perfect though; so we would encourage leaders to adopt this guidance in daily life and use the environment of scenario based tests and exercises to practice adapting to the changing context of a crisis.
Showing posts with label crisis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crisis. Show all posts
Wednesday, 4 February 2015
Tuesday, 6 May 2014
LEAD...FOLLOW...OR GET OUT OF THE WAY (PART 1)
Leadership?
When was the last time you were asked to define leadership? Its the kind of thing we know what it feels like when its good or bad, but its hard (and maybe unnecessary) to define. It might help to think of leadership as both a noun and verb; in other words its not just about what leaders do, its a phenomenon centred on interactions. Sometimes using these two lenses can be helpful, especially in challenging times.
Grappling with this concept I formed a view that there are three dimensions to leadership, namely the leader, their followers and the context(s) in which they are operating. These three dimensions interact to produce 'leadership' (noun); when the leader and followers 'connect', working in tune with each other and with the context in which they find themselves, the result feels good and is effective. When one dimension moves out of synch the whole suffers; leadership happens when all the dimensions align. What then of the context of a crisis? In Part 1 of this two part blog I'm going to briefly explore something of the art of followership in a crisis.
Followership
Followership
Leading commentators classify followers according to their level of engagement with the leader and with the organisation. In 2008 Barbara Kellerman described four groups in her book "Followership":
- Bystanders observe but deliberately stand aside, offering tacit support for 'whoever and whatever constitutes the status quo.'
- Participants are engaged to varying degrees and will invest effort to 'try and have an impact.'
- Activists 'feel strongly about their leaders' and will work hard for or against them. Very engaged.
- Diehards are utterly dedicated to their perception of the leader and will give everything to act accordingly.
Followers wishing to have an impact ('the engaged') will use their engagement to actively support or undermine leaders; so from the leader's perspective followers may be good or bad, with positive or negative influences on 'leadership' (noun).
So What?
So how might this rudimentary understanding help in relation to managing crisis? I offer 5 points for consideration to add value to the quality of your followership in a crisis.
So What?
So how might this rudimentary understanding help in relation to managing crisis? I offer 5 points for consideration to add value to the quality of your followership in a crisis.
Crisis disrupts the balance. By its very nature a crisis will disrupt the balance between the 3 dimensions of 'leadership'; its inevitable. This provides an additional challenge for leaders and followers alike. The context has changed and so may the roles and behaviours of everyone involved. Adjustment from the norm will be required to re-synchronise the 3 dimensions; this doesn't constitute a free for all, but rather a concerted and well managed effort. Its important for followers to understand these dynamics and react positively to enable meaningful progress in the early stages of a crisis.
Understand the context. Different contexts require different types and speeds of action. The situation may require deference to experts, a degree of debate or just some quick decisions and action. In the earliest stages of a crisis lengthy discussions to decide the optimal path are unlikely to help. Sometimes however, the situation (including a leader's behaviour), may require a more challenging approach from followers. Understanding the context and adjusting your followership behaviour accordingly are key.
Sometimes we lead, but all of us will follow sometimes. Part of understanding the context may also be recognising whether you are playing a leader's role or a follower's role. As a C Suite Exec you may be in charge, or you may be following a designated CMT leader or perhaps deferring to a subject matter expert. The same logic holds true throughout the organisation; where individuals may sometimes be leading, sometimes following. As a follower, its important to understand your role and recognise that this role may change throughout the crisis.
Stay in lane. Its sometimes difficult for a 'day to day' leader to play a followers role. As a follower who 'normally' leads, you may need to consciously suppress your desire to step in or to take over, especially in times of crisis; egos to the back, collective needs to the fore!
Bystanders incubate crisis. Prior to and during a crisis the less engaged followers will not say or do anything to change the status quo, no matter what they might really feel. These followers incubate crisis. By remaining silent or by failing to challenge leaders, crisis may be inevitable and some unchallenged decisions within a crisis may simply exacerbate the problem. Speaking up may be whats required, and recognising when its helpful to do so is vital.
So effective crisis management is also dependant upon effective followers who understand the context and adjust their behaviour and actions accordingly, recognising the need to play different roles accordingly, to maintain a balance with the leader and the context. And similarly there are lessons for leaders, which will be explored in Part 2.
Friday, 7 March 2014
Communicating with Employees during a Crisis
In our previous post we looked at some
tips for successful crisis communications. Beverly Lowry rejoins us for this post to look specifically at the
importance of communicating with employees during a crisis.
Whilst many companies have plans in
place to communicate with their external stakeholders during a crisis, few seem to have plans for
communicating with their employees. Sometimes, amidst the pressure and urgency of crisis, organisations overlook the importance of communicating internally and too often the focus is solely on dealing with the media and the
customer response.
Communicating
with employees during a crisis and afterwards is essential if an organisation
wants to work through the crisis with the respect and co-operation of its
workforce. If your organisation is under scrutiny,
then unless you talk to your employees and provide them with as much
information as you can, you will inadvertently fuel the rumour mill and encourage your
employees to rely on other sources of information.
So, a crucial element of your crisis
communications plan must be a section about how you will
communicate with your employees. Here
are a few things to consider:
- Plan which channels you are going to use: Which channel is the fastest and most effective way of reaching your employees? It may be email, the intranet or employee briefings, or a combination of these, depending on what works best for your organisation. Don't discount using social media, and ensure the crisis isn't your first foray into that channel.
- Consider how to reach shift workers and those away from base: Have you got enough managers to hold a short briefing at the start of each shift? Consider how you will communicate with your overseas workers in different time zones and those based in locations across the UK and Ireland. Consider also how quickly you can issue internal communications if the crisis occurs out of office hours.
- Leadership: Employees want to see leaders during a crisis. Some chief executives hold regular employee briefings to explain what is being done about the situation and to answer questions. This demonstrates leadership and openness and can be useful when dealing with a major issue. Your senior team should be visible throughout the crisis, talking to and reassuring your people.
- Two-way dialogue: It’s important to address your employees’ concerns during a crisis by providing a forum for people to ask questions and to raise issues. This can be through face to face briefings, online forums, team meetings, whatever works best for your organisation. Some of your employees will be at the sharp end dealing with your customers. Informed employees reflect well on your company and they will be better placed to provide good customer service. As a general rule, it’s very important to issue the same facts internally as externally. You have to expect that information circulated internally will reach the public domain.
- Maintain the integrity of your communication: Your communication needs to be accurate and candid. It’s important to address the difficult issues. It’s essential that your employees trust your organisation’s information and they will only do so if you demonstrate that you are willing to talk honestly about the situation. This means being open even when your organisation has made a mistake.
Keep an eye out for our future posts on the use of Social Media in managing crises. Make sure you don't miss out by following our blog, using the links on the right....
Wednesday, 19 February 2014
Top Tips for Crisis Communication
In a previous post we looked at the top five tips for decision-making during a crisis. In this post, communications expert Beverly Lowry shares her top five tips for communicating during a crisis.
Whatever the issue or incident, your organisation’s reputation depends on your ability to communicate effectively. Here are five things to consider.
1. Respond quickly
- Have a clear call-out procedure to inform the communications representative in your organisation about any major issue or incident.
- Aim to have your first media statement ready within one hour of an incident.
- Nominate and prepare a senior manager to be your broadcast spokesperson.
2. Get additional resources
- If possible, set up a 24-hour communications response so that your organisation can respond quickly to developing media and social media issues.
- Make sure you have sufficient people to cover all aspects of the communications response, such as, writing statements, answering media calls, managing social media sites and preparing employee communications materials.
3. Provide regular updates
- Issue regular media statements as the information becomes available.
- Keep your employees, customers and other stakeholders updated each day.
4. Keep your statements factual
- Make sure your statements are an accurate and factual record of events.
- Don’t speculate about what has happened.
- Don’t be pressurised into guessing the facts.
- Don’t comment about issues that are the domain of regulators or other investigatory organisations.
5. Provide the same information to all stakeholders
- Keep all internal and external stakeholder groups informed with the same set of facts. What goes internally will go externally.
Tuesday, 26 November 2013
Decisions, Decisions, Decisions!
We’ve been talking on
our blog recently about supporting crisis decision making through information
management, and attempting to speed up the OODA Loop. On the last post we
highlighted the principles of managing decisions and making sure they achieve
what you intended them to. This post looks at how to actually take those crisis
decisions in the first instance. It is useful to have a decision-making system
that is thorough enough to be effective but not so laborious as to induce
delay. We also need a process that allows for intuition and experience to play
a part but doesn’t allow for sloppy analysis. The next seven questions are just such a
process.
(1) What is the situation and what does it mean
to you? - Understand as much about the situation as you can. Don’t ignore
aspects just because the information isn’t there or you don’t understand it.
Identify your critical information requirements and get them resolved. Once you
have a grip on what is actually going on be clear on the meaning for you, your
staff and your clients and any other interested parties.
(2) What end state result do I need to achieve
and why? Define the end state that you need to reach and why that is the
case, that is the unifying purpose behind what you are doing. This will inform and
focus the decisions you take. Make sure others are clear on this end state and
its rationale, as this will inform their decisions as well.
(3) What effects need to take place to get to
the end state? Define the key effects that need to be achieved to deliver
the end state. Effects are not tasks but rather the results of tasks. Examples
of effects might include enhanced staff confidence, client reassurance or
favourable reporting by the media.
(4) How can the effects best be achieved? Decide
how the effects can best be achieved and when and where this should take place.
This will help you set down the tasks that are required to deliver the effects.
(5) What resources are required? Take a
look at the tasks you have defined. See if they can be combined in some fashion
and then decide who is best to undertake each task. Allocate sufficient resources
to enable the tasks to be carried out.
(6) In what sequence do the tasks need to
occur? Set down the sequence that the tasks need to be carried out in to
achieve the desired effects. The sequencing of these tasks is effectively the
plan.
(7) How are the tasks to be controlled? Put in place the measures that will enable the conduct of the tasks to be monitored and controlled. This may include aspects such as timings for completion, reporting processes, demarcated lines of responsibility, geographical boundaries etc.
Sunday, 13 October 2013
Crisis Decision Making- Top 5 Tips
In previous posts we examined information management and operating a fast OODA Loop. This post looks at some tools to help crisis decision-making. Here are five things to consider.
1. Key
Questions: Have a system to guide your decision
making that analyses the situation and allows you to use your experience
and intuition. Think about the questions you need to ask and write them down in advance. They should help you (1) understand what is
going on and the implications of that, (2) appreciate what needs to be done and
why, (3) be clear on where your priority lies and (4)
identify, resource and co-ordinate tasks. Practice this technique to make its use
second nature - rehearse, rehearse, rehearse!
2. Get Your Intention Across: Remember those completing a task may encounter unforeseen problems. Be clear about what needs done (the task) and why (the intent - unifying the purpose of many tasks). Understanding the intent affords your teams the freedom to adapt the task if they encounter a difficulty and still achieve the intent.
2. Get Your Intention Across: Remember those completing a task may encounter unforeseen problems. Be clear about what needs done (the task) and why (the intent - unifying the purpose of many tasks). Understanding the intent affords your teams the freedom to adapt the task if they encounter a difficulty and still achieve the intent.
3. Achieving
a Focus: There will be lots going on so, to avoid
dissipation of effort, make it clear where the focus lies. Define what is
critical for success and make sure everyone knows and is working towards that. It can help to define the end state - what will success look like?
4. Using
Resources: Resources are scarce so use them wisely.
Allocate resources to those tasks that support your focus. Others will
have to wait. Remember that not everything will go to plan, so have spare
capacity.
5. Using
Time Effectively: The one resource that can’t be
regenerated is time. If you have to take decisions then think about those who
will have to implement them. Leave them the time to do that. Work out how much
time is available between starting the decision process and the resulting
actions needing to take place. Then use 1/3rd of that time to take the decision
and leave 2/3rds for everyone else to actual carry out the tasks the decisions generate.
Our next item will be focusing on a handy tool when it comes to decision making that allows you to combine thoroughness whilst not sacrificing experience, gut feel and intuition so keep watching and following. To avoid missing out why not simply opt to follow our blog by submitting your email address. You will get each post emailed to you as they are posted.
Our next item will be focusing on a handy tool when it comes to decision making that allows you to combine thoroughness whilst not sacrificing experience, gut feel and intuition so keep watching and following. To avoid missing out why not simply opt to follow our blog by submitting your email address. You will get each post emailed to you as they are posted.
Thursday, 12 September 2013
Managing Information and Actions in a Crisis
In an earlier post we talked about the need to manage the process by which crisis decisions are taken and talked about the OODA Loop (read Decision Making or Analysis Paralysis). In this post we going to present some concepts around how to speed up the OODA Loop. If you can get your decision making processes to happen faster than the crisis is unfolding then your decisions stand to be more effective. On top of that, making a larger number of quicker decisions, each one correcting the errors of the previous one, is likely to help you reach an optimum solution faster than if you wait for total clarity. So what to do?CRIP: Establish and maintain a full understanding of the situation. This is sometimes referred to as the Common Recognised Information Picture. It is built up of all available validated information. It is not a chronological list but a contextualised picture that can inform decisions. Date/Time stamp it and keep it up to date, even when the decision makers are not meeting. Use information pull (gathering information in) and information push (people and organisations knowing instinctively to forward information) to achieve this.Strategic Aims: Make sure the Crisis Management Team establish the Strategic Aims for managing the crisis early on. These may even be drafted in a plan for confirmation or adjustment on the day. They won’t change very often but they set the tone for the response, driving information management and response. If the top aim is ‘safety and staff welfare’ this will determine that things progress differently for any given situation than if itwere ‘corporate client entertainment events’. Sounds obvious and simple but it is often overlooked.
Key Issues: Identify the Key Issues of the moment and when decisions have to be made by. Remember also that people need time to carry out the actions that result from the decisions made. Key Issues are those that arrive from looking at the CRIP through the lens of the Strategic Aims. They require management as they reflect the priorities that have been set. Use talented managers to select Key issues and identify options prior to the CMT meeting up.
Manage Actions: Decisions need actions to make them a reality. Taking a decision is not the same as things happening. Have a process, team and resources to break decisions down into actions, allocate those actions and monitor performance. Update the CMT on progress so that they can adjust decisions accordingly.
Friday, 30 August 2013
The Sum of the Parts...
Have you noticed the recent chatter about divorcing continuity and risk management? It seems to me that this mindset is anchored in a cloudy, blinkered mentality. At R2 we're really clear about the value of both risk management and continuity, and more importantly about how they fit together and, backed by a capable and flexible team, how they produce resilience. We're not renowned for our algebra, but there's one formula we know works well. R + C2 = Resilience; that is to say, combining effective Risk management, Continuity management and a Capability vested in people provides real Resilience.
As business owners its obvious to us that business and risk go hand in hand, both in terms of understanding the risks you are presented with and in relation to the amount of risk you are prepared to take to achieve your goals. Fair to say therefore that if you're running an organisation you're involved in risk. Accepting that risk is the 'effect of uncertainty on objectives' it stands to reason that being able to deal with this uncertainty, reduce it when possible and respond when it disrupts are crucial skills for any organisation. Its a mistake to expect risk management and continuity to work independently; in fact its our view that continuity management provides key tools that form a key element of the overall risk strategy.
To explain; there is no point in assessing the risk of every conceivable eventuality when its the risk to those things that are most crucial to your success (processes, information, resources) that should occupy your conceptual and physical efforts. In other words if the risk has no bearing on your short or long term business objectives then why manage it? Best to focus on what matters most. Business continuity's business impact assessment provides a great vehicle for developing this focus at the strategic, tactical and operational levels. Done properly it provides a focus for risk, relevant to the whole organisation and its objectives, not just to continuity or operations. Similarly continuity strategies and plans provide the treatment for many risks, both in terms of mitigation and response. In these regards, risk and continuity work very well together to achieve resilience; keep these two disciplines in silos at your peril.
More importantly, despite the best risk management efforts, there's no such thing as 'risk free' if you're going to make progress; ships are safest in the harbour, but that's not really what ships are for. So, given that you will be setting sail, its essential to have the resilience to recognise, monitor and deal with uncertainty and residual risk (the risk that you know is there but cant remove) as well as being resilient enough to deal with those unexpected and unforeseen risks (events that 'blindside' you). In this regard its the capability of your people and the flexibility of your plans that will see you through the unforeseen.
Risk, continuity and capability: the whole is greater than the sum of the parts. Break the silos and combine these components for real resilience.
(With thanks to John McKee from Linkubator for the ships metaphor!)
Friday, 16 August 2013
Lessons from Christine, Usain and Mo...
...IT TAKES PREPARATION.
Did you see Christine Ohuruogu win her gold medal this week? Incredible. It was a display of determination and a world beating performance pulled from the top drawer when it mattered most. Usain Bolt produced his magic again and Mo Farah just completed a double double - two golds at both the Olympics and the World Championships. Of course these athletes are only three amongst hundreds who have been preparing for years to achieve success under the most intense pressure.
"Let me tell you sonny, we'll be fine. I've been in business for over twenty years and not much gets past me. We don't need a plan and we certainly don't have the time to practice." Or the age old classic "Of course we have a plan... I think we exercised it a few years ago."
I wonder how many gold medals Usain, Christine and Mo would be wearing if they adopted the same approach? How on earth can it be possible to avoid meaningful practice and preparation and expect to win when the stakes are highest? Whether its the Olympics, the World Championships or the equally high pressure atmosphere of a crisis, the simple truth is that failing to prepare only leads to defeat.
So the lesson is simple. If you want your business to avoid meltdown in the midst of a crisis, its essential to prepare as thoroughly as you can. And that means having a plan that fits your business; not a copy of someone else's or a template from the internet. It means having people who understand their roles and responsibilities in a crisis and above all it means training your people and putting the whole lot through their paces regularly. Make your training as realistic as you can and judge the progression - Rome wasn't built in a day. By training and practising your teams will know what to do in a crisis - they'll perform on the big occasion. More importantly they'll develop the confidence and flexibility to be able to cope with the unexpected. And, by it's very definition your crisis will involve the unexpected, so you need to be ready or you don't stand a chance.
So learn from the World Champs. Preparation leads to success under the most intense pressure, amongst hungry competitors who want to defeat you. And remember, a plan that hasn't been exercised is no plan at all - its the capability that counts.
So the lesson is simple. If you want your business to avoid meltdown in the midst of a crisis, its essential to prepare as thoroughly as you can. And that means having a plan that fits your business; not a copy of someone else's or a template from the internet. It means having people who understand their roles and responsibilities in a crisis and above all it means training your people and putting the whole lot through their paces regularly. Make your training as realistic as you can and judge the progression - Rome wasn't built in a day. By training and practising your teams will know what to do in a crisis - they'll perform on the big occasion. More importantly they'll develop the confidence and flexibility to be able to cope with the unexpected. And, by it's very definition your crisis will involve the unexpected, so you need to be ready or you don't stand a chance.
So learn from the World Champs. Preparation leads to success under the most intense pressure, amongst hungry competitors who want to defeat you. And remember, a plan that hasn't been exercised is no plan at all - its the capability that counts.
Labels:
Athletics,
crisis,
Exercise,
Mo Farah,
Preparation,
Training,
Usain Bolt
Friday, 9 August 2013
Decision Making or Analysis Paralysis?
How's Your Crisis Navigation...?
A crisis brings many pressures to bear. Leaders at all levels will be faced with choices about the 'least worst' option, with little time, inadequate resources and sparse information upon which to rely; they'll have to navigate the challenges of the crisis. The path ahead won't be clear. And quite often crisis leaders run the risk of becoming trapped by their need for certainty and simplicity, while the crisis provides for neither. In these circumstances it's easy to become stunned into indecision, searching for a complete picture, overwhelmed by the 'noise' and making little progress.
US Air Force pilot, John Boyd, expressed the logic of his decision making in aerial combat as the 'OODA Loop' - Observe, Orient, Decide, Act. Observation is about improving your awareness of the situation, whilst accepting you won't gain a complete picture. Orientation talks to 'sense making' of what you've observed, relating it to what you already know and to your experience. Options might be generated at this point and tough choices follow. Decisions are sometimes easier said than done, but decisions there must be if any progress is to be made. And for all of this to have any effect, the decisions must generate coherent actions that lead to progress. Don't forget it's a loop, so after the action there'll be more observation to see the effect of the action, and so begins another cycle of the loop... you get the picture.
Simple as this may sound in theory, many crisis teams struggle to provide themselves with quality information, making their decisions more difficult and less likely to have a positive effect. To help your crisis team make optimal decisions it's key that they are neither swamped (leading to paralysis) nor misled (leading to irrelevant decisions). They should be presented with as clear a picture as possible based on the right information (filtered - not every possible piece of information) and anchored through the key issues in play. And that's where many teams come unhinged; they have neither a system of information management, nor the means to bring it to bear. The more complex your organisation the more of a problem this is likely to create. It's therefore key to have a system that coordinates the OODA loop effectively to give the decision makers the information they need to make relevant decisions that will have a positive effect.
Our recent piece of thought leadership draws on some experience in designing and delivering just such a system; in fact a whole crisis management facility and the accompanying procedures were designed and built around this very logic. All that's needed to help your crisis decision making is the means to gather information, filter it, join it together and present it effectively - all enabled by a skilled team and some well thought through and rehearsed procedures. OODA - not paralysis.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








